The Myth of Normal by Gabor Maté – Book Review

A big thank you to my hypnotherapy colleagues, John Black, Emma Lousada, Davinder Sunner, Caroline Parsons, Catherine O’Connell and Yung-Fang Chen for making Book Club (in June 2024) so engaging. Here is a summary of our view of the book in case of interest to others.

Summary

The book is BIG. It covers big themes and provides big insights. It provokes powerful penny dropping moments that are likely to leave you really thinking.

The title, ‘The Myth of Normal‘ says it all, because the book is all about how we readily accept and normalise aspects of our lives that are in fact, very far from normal and are even detrimental and harmful to our health and wellness.

At its core, the book focuses on stress and the impact that stress can have on our bodies, our health, our life expectancy and whether certain disease states manifest or not, within us.

From the wide range of research referred to throughout the book, it is clear that stress, and the physiological changes that happen within us, can have a profoundly negative effect on our health and lives. This is particularly the case if stress is long standing or unresolved.

Stress is a high-risk factor

Stress is a high-risk factor, sometimes very high, sometimes deadly. Yet, Gabor argues, it is an aspect and key causative factor of disease that is often inadequately considered (or sometimes not considered at all) by healthcare professionals when working with patients.

The stress response, when short term and temporary, is of course, a natural, important adaptive survival mechanism to life’s challenges and opportunities but when it is chronic and enduring, it can take a heavy toll.

Stress comes from many sources

The book outlines a range of issues that can give rise to long term stress. These harmful aspects of our lives are often normalised and overlooked and include:

The author proposes that these conditions of our life are becoming more abnormal and are the reason why, despite significant medical advances and investment in healthcare, we are getting sicker. This is evidenced for example through the increasing incidence of type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, heart, circulatory and neurological conditions, child and adult obesity. The number of people taking prescribed medications and the rise of relatively new conditions like ADHD).

Disproportionate harm

As well as the effects of stress on individuals, the book sets out, very powerfully, how groups of people who have been subject to discrimination, injustice and social harm (e.g. people of colour, first nations people and women) have a higher incidence of some of the most serious neurological conditions. Conditions for which the incidence is growing and growing disproportionally within certain groups. This is an unacceptable cruel, double injustice.

The book is a wakeup call on a grand scale.

It is essential reading for all of us.

Main themes

The book takes a comprehensive look at stress and how our adaptations to it can shape our emotions, behaviours and relationships and even our personality (or what we thought was us).  

These adaptations are not our true selves (the people we were born to be) but responses we adopted (understandably) during earlier years, at a time when we had neither the life experience, power, or choice to do anything else. This shaping and moulding of us, can become habituated, so much so that we can believe they are us.

The book draws on much research which shows a link between intense, unresolved, or prolonged emotional states (like anger or fear) and how certain disease states are more likely to manifest.

Mindbody

The concept of ‘mindbody’ (purposely not hyphenated) is central to the book and is used to show how deeply our minds and body are connected. From the book it would be true to say that there is no body without mind and no mind without body. Therefore stressful prolonged emotions are felt and experienced by the body (and vice versa) and can take a significant toll.

The author suggests that very few diseases are in fact a result of genetics and that our relationships, environment, how we were treated, and upbringing are very significant (and often overlooked) factors.

Trauma can cross generations

Factors in our environment that can shape our emotions, behaviours and health status include the context of our parents’ lives and their emotional states, even before we were conceived. The research clearly shows that trauma can easily be passed on from parents to children and become multi-generational.

The author suggests that ultimately stress arises in us when we:

  1. Don’t receive the love, safety and care that we needed (a lack of attachment)
  2. Aren’t allowed to be true selves (a lack of authenticity)

Trauma as an inner wounding

The book shows that when these stress-inducing issues are experienced in a significant enough way, an inner, psychological wounding can take place. Gabor defines this inner wounding as trauma and defines trauma as, ‘a psychic injury lodged in our nervous system, mind and body, lasting long past the originating incident, triggerable at any moment’. Trauma can cause a fracturing of the self and one’s relationship to the world and this is why he defines healing as a ‘natural movement towards wholeness’, ‘self-retrieval’ and ‘recovery of lost parts’.

Gabor explains that trauma can be experienced as capital T trauma (where people have been abused, hurt, neglected etc) or small t trauma, an almost universal phenomenon where less memorable but hurtful things happen to us or where good things did not happen that should have done. These inner wounds and our adaptations to them can result in long term stress and be passed across generations.

Healing – seeing what’s there, then making choices

Gabor suggests that almost all of us have these woundings and that the start to healing involves people acknowledging their own suffering. From this, it is possible to see how we have adapted to what happened and then to see that choices exist about how we respond now. From this we can start to take those choices and be fully present.

Gabor quotes Peter Levine is saying that “all traumatic events are stressful but not all stressful events are traumatic”. He then goes on to explain that “an event is traumatising or retraumatising only if it renders one diminished which is to say psychologically or physically more limited, in a way that persists”. He also describes a common and tragic consequence of trauma in that it fosters a “shame-based” and negative perception of ourselves (something that is commonly expressed by clients at the start of the healing journey).

Disease as process

Gabor sees disease, not as something that happens in a moment, but part of a much longer process involving the flow of interactions between us and the contexts of our life.

As a medical doctor, he reflects on aspects of medical practice and how, for example, the context and conditions of people’s life is often missed out entirely in assessments, diagnosis, conversations and treatment plans. And yet, our contexts and psychological lives seem to be a crucial factor in many disease states.

Gabor argues that our inner wounds, and our adaptations to them, known or unconscious, (for example repressed anger and emotions) pose significant risks to our life, wellness and morbidity. Stress is therefore, a high risk factor and crucial to help people reduce.

The book

The book is necessarily uncomfortable in places but illuminating, funny, forgiving and hopeful.

Reading it may well change you for the good (both personally and professionally). It may, help make sense of some things in your own life and help avoid unintentional harms we might cause in others.

Book Club Scores (out of 10)

10, 10, 10, 8, 8, 6. Average (8.6)

Highly Recommended.

The Myth of Normal in a few words

Deeply profound and challenging, unsettling and revealing, profound and important, very current, wordy, honest, thought provoking

What colleagues liked about the book

The compassion and a no-blame paradigm. The mix of evidence, research, personal stories and reflections. The parts about trauma (and its significant impact) are very clear and powerful as are the sections on addiction. The emphasis on people’s psychological life and how important it is to consider these when seeking to treat people, medically. The book is darkly funny in places and there is much honesty and humility shown by the author about his own mistakes and limitations. We also really liked the power of the personal reflections that the book invoked in us.

What we didn’t like so much 

In the scheme of things, these were very minor complaints but included: being too wordy, the use of overly flamboyant language, not generally used. It was more focused on the problems and less on solutions (this was acknowledged by the author). The accents used by the narrator of the audio book were grating.

The Book and Solution Focused Hypnotherapy

The book didn’t so much introduce new themes given that our training in Solution Focused hypnotherapy covers in some detail the stress response. The book did however strengthen the importance of many issues. These include:

Conclusion

Overall, this was a fantastic read and everyone who’d read the book said that they were glad they did.

Personally, it has shaped my practice and thinking in very helpful ways. It has broadened my knowledge and I am deeply grateful to the author for the colossal effort this book must have taken to write and for the insights, foresight and compassion within the writing.

Thank you Gabor Maté

Take good care

Andy